European Football Forum

A football forum specialising in European league and cup football as well as international & off topic discussion!


    Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Share

    Tarun

    Number of posts: 2909
    Age: 33
    Supports: Juventus
    Favourite Player: Del Piero, Gianluigi Buffon
    Registration date: 2007-01-16

    Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by Tarun on Wed May 16, 2007 1:27 pm

    Platini wants penalty box officials

    Uefa chief wants to follow American football

    Wednesday May 16, 2007
    Guardian Unlimited

    New Uefa president Michel Platini is ready to revolutionise the "outmoded" world of refereeing by using two more officials in each match.
    Platini, who was elected to office in January, wants to put an official behind each goal to help rule on penalty box infringements. The former France attacking midfielder believes that would be better than using technology, which he claims would "dehumanise" football.

    "My idea is to increase the number of officials," he told France Football. "To referee with just three people, it is outmoded. Three officials cannot see everything. I am proposing two extra officials, over-45s who don't need to run because they would stay behind the goals.

    "We must show the world that we are against injustice and that we are trying to do more to eliminate errors. As for using electronic systems, that risks dehumanising football."
    Platini believes the sport should take a leaf out of American football's book, and use officials who highlight infringements by throwing a flag on to the field of play.

    "Why not take the example shown by American football, who uses referees aged 60 or over, who signal fouls with their yellow flag," he added.

    robert

    Number of posts: 5672
    Age: 29
    Supports: Manchester United
    Favourite Player: Giggs
    Registration date: 2006-08-14

    Re: Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by robert on Wed May 16, 2007 1:31 pm

    Diving is still hard to see at times, even having multiple cameras, multiple angles, multiple replays proves inconclusive so why would we put cataract ridden officials policing the box.


    Last edited by on Wed May 16, 2007 1:47 pm; edited 1 time in total

    DS

    Number of posts: 12952
    Age: 26
    Supports: Manchester United , Bayern Munich
    Registration date: 2006-08-07

    Re: Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by DS on Wed May 16, 2007 1:45 pm

    Not the worst idea ,probably will solve the ball crossing the line and will be closer to the area to see penalties or not.

    DS

    Number of posts: 12952
    Age: 26
    Supports: Manchester United , Bayern Munich
    Registration date: 2006-08-07

    Re: Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by DS on Wed May 16, 2007 1:46 pm

    But too many officials , the job of linesman and ref would be limited.

    toon h

    Number of posts: 8682
    Age: 38
    Supports: FC Barcelona
    Registration date: 2006-08-07

    Re: Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by toon h on Wed May 16, 2007 1:49 pm

    we can also place two more in the goalmouth. Any ricochets off them would certainly increase the spectacle.

    The-Frank-Tavern

    Number of posts: 8505
    Age: 43
    Supports: Atlético de Madrid
    Registration date: 2006-08-07

    Re: Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by The-Frank-Tavern on Wed May 16, 2007 1:53 pm

    i've heard worse suggestions coming out of his mouth

    DS

    Number of posts: 12952
    Age: 26
    Supports: Manchester United , Bayern Munich
    Registration date: 2006-08-07

    Re: Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by DS on Wed May 16, 2007 1:58 pm

    The-Frank-Tavern wrote:i've heard worse suggestions coming out of his mouth

    Thats what I meant.Just trying to give it a try but its a no hoper.
    lol!

    toon h

    Number of posts: 8682
    Age: 38
    Supports: FC Barcelona
    Registration date: 2006-08-07

    Re: Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by toon h on Wed May 16, 2007 2:03 pm

    if it wasn't for these test balloons coming from Blatter or Platini you might start to wonder whether they were alive or working...

    Oleguerisntthatbad

    Number of posts: 7180
    Age: 34
    Registration date: 2006-08-10

    Re: Your Opinions: Platini wants penalty box officials

    Post by Oleguerisntthatbad on Wed May 16, 2007 4:41 pm

    What a load of nonesense.. why spend money and energy on something that isn't going to change the game..

    Would be better to spend the energy on changing the way the big tournaments work..

      Current date/time is Mon May 21, 2012 10:39 pm